Finished the Scribing quest chain in ESO!
My overall thoughts:
1) Votary Nahlia did end up feeling a bit like what we would call a Mary Sue, back in the day, and not in the "be cringe be free" fun way; I think this would've been alleviated simply by sharing her importance with the other Votaries who were present and who we even briefly meet and interact with, but instead having to constantly turn to this random OC Don't Steal writer's blorbo felt a bit exhausting
(it also felt a bit unearned when the Crow just, hands her ownership of the Scholarium, like hey let me talk to you about how this bosmer is an absolute dingdong with no leadership skills and only minimal intellect or curiosity, even though I will admit she's a whizz with portals)
2) I think the steps where you just found the purple circles, stood in them, and dispelled wards needed to be cut way back or eliminated entirely tbh, I didn't mind doing the various chores the Luminaries sent you on (I actually liked this, gives you a reason to explore some different areas) but having to just..............stand in circle, press button, over and over, was not super fun or challenging
3) the attempts at a wise riddles god and a whimsical trickster god (or spirit or guardian whatever the Luminaries count as) were not successful for me at all
(I'm not good at riddles/wordplay which is why I don't write those things, if you're gonna do the thing you have to really workshop it and commit)
anyways it was close to being a perfectly fine quest chain and I even thought the ending was sweet, but good lord making me run around to press A in a circle eight thousand times is extremely giving FF14 in terms of pointless quest-padding