Last week I finally got around to watching The Sweatbox, which is a documentary about the creation of the Emperor's New Groove, and how it transformed into that from Kingdom of the Sun.
Wikipedia describes it like this:
It illustrated the slow and painful transformation from Kingdom of the Sun to The Emperor's New Groove, including director Roger Allers, musician Sting, artists and voice cast being dismayed by the new direction. The film's major theme is creative-executive conflicts.
And
The crew then present what they have finished so far to executive producers Thomas Schumacher and Peter Schneider in the titular sweatbox, the room where they screen their half-finished product. However, the producers are harshly dissatisfied and demand that the film be redone, though they underhandedly admit that they liked the "love song" and the "llama song".
And that's the sort of tone I've heard about it having every time it's come up, that it's a documentary about producers Not Understanding Art and Almost Ruining A Project and whatever, but...
Okay, so to start with, all of the creatives in it to me give me a vibe of, understanding that this is just part of the job. Sometimes your project just isn't working and has to change. They talk quite a bit about how Emperor's New Groove in particular was a deeply collaborative project that they hoped people could bring up things that aren't working so they can be changed into something that does work -- Sting almost walks off of the project near the end because the ending isn't working for him, the creatives (and Roy Disney) read his letter on the subject, agree with him, and change the ending. This is not a project on which people were fighting over Their Vision
Also the producers seemed very aware that they were dealing with people's Art and tried to be kind when giving feedback -- the wikipedia note that a comment was "underhanded" is wild to me. And also that comment is very funny in retrospect given that both songs, and nearly all songs, ended up cut from the movie.
But also also... they were right. The movie as described before the producer screening is a mess. It's a Prince and the Pauper story in which the main character is a poor llama farmer who teaches the vain emperor how to be a better ruler and also the emperor is turned into a llama while the farmer has to rule in his stead while also there's a love story between a princess and the farmer who is pretending to be the emperor while also Yzma is trying to take over while also there's a god of bureaucracy while also,
There's so much going on in this movie, there's no way it would have succeeded if they'd run with what they were making. And the movie it became did extremely decently for itself, especially considering the environment it was released into.
The producers did their job. It's a necessary job for that sort of creative work. Y'all are just projecting your inability to work in a collaborative creative field onto these professional directors and animators.